I. PURPOSE OF FELLOWS' STATEMENT ON UNIVERSITY
OF CALIFORNIA CONTRACT
Los Alamos National
Laboratory (LANL) exists to assure, through
science
and technology, the national security of the United States.
To accomplish this purpose, LANL must produce high-quality,
multidisciplinary,
classified and unclassified
scientific research and development
for solving
complex problems of national importance. In the past,
the LANL Fellows* have strongly supported the Department of Energy's
(DOE) selection of the University of California (UC)
as the LANL
contractor.1 At this critical
time in LANL's history,
the LANL Fellows wish to
reaffirm their support for UCs continued
scientific management of the Laboratory and for the importance of
its nurturing environment for scientific
excellence.
II. LANL MISSIONS REQUIRE THE BEST
MULTIDISCIPLINARY SCIENCE POSSIBLE
LANL has missions in
the areas of nuclear stockpile stewardship, threat reduction, and
strategic and supporting research. To fulfill these missions, LANL
must have world-class competency in a number of diverse scientific
disciplines. LANL must bring together the best people and finest
equipment in an interactive research environment focused on finding
solutions to these national challenges. The continuous association
with UC has enabled LANL to achieve both goals: to be a world leader
in diversified sciences and to be able to recognize, meet, and solve
relevant national challenges, ranging from small, specialized
problems to large-scale interdisciplinary projects. (The first such
large-scale interdisciplinary project was the Manhattan
Project.)
III. GREAT SCIENCE DEMANDS GREAT
PEOPLE
LANL's mission and programs require great science,
and the quality of its science depends directly on the quality of its
people. For over 50 years, LANL has benefited from having
world-renowned scientists on its staff (see the Appendix). In many
cases, these scientists chose to work at Los Alamos because of the
prestigious employment with UC, the nation's largest and most
acclaimed public research institution. The UC employee benefits
package is another important element when attempting to hire the best
and brightest in a highly competitive marketplace. LANL attracts,
hires, and retains superior scientific staff for three major reasons:
LANL's excellent reputation as a place where one can do cutting-edge
science, the strategic national importance of our work, and the
prestige and integrity of the University of California. These UC
advantages are vitally important today and will remain so in the
future.
IV. SCIENTIFIC EXCELLENCE REQUIRES
EXCHANGES OF IDEAS AND PEER REVIEW
Scientific excellence
and integrity require an interactive workplace and collegial
atmosphere to allow creative thought and free-flowing exchange of
new, sometimes controversial, ideas. LANL staff must be able to
interact with colleagues worldwide at conferences and through journal
publications that provide important peer reviews and stimulate new
concepts in our unclassified science (that often later finds
application to our classified work). Consistent with requirements of
security, similar exchange of ideas and peer review are no less
important to the creativity of the community of weapons scientists at
the national laboratories. UC has always demanded scientific
integrity, which is absolutely crucial for LANL to be successful in
its national security missions. UC has supported the Laboratory's
efforts to strive for the ultimate science-based workplace. Under UC
leadership, LANL has thrived for over 50
years.
V. LANL FEDERAL CONTRACT MUST HAVE A
SCIENCE-IN-NATIONAL-SERVICE FOCUS
Recognized worldwide
for its excellence in scientific research, UC also has extensive
experience overseeing large laboratories including Los Alamos,
Lawrence Livermore, and Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratories. For
more than half a century, UC has worked intensively with Los Alamos
and understands the scope and special nature of our work. UC
performs its oversight of LANL as a public service, helping the
Laboratory provide science while protecting the information it
applies to our nations security. UC has worked with LANL to
improve operations and ensure a safe and secure workplace, and it has
been responsive to DOE's changing requirements. UC uses results of
performance-based, peer-reviewed science management in its oversight
of LANL.
UC influences science and operations at LANL in the
following important ways. The LANL Director is an officer of UC,
similar to the Chancellor of a UC campus, and reports to the UC
President. At five-year intervals, a board appointed by the UC
President reviews the performance of the Laboratory Director. The UC
President's Council on the National Laboratories has been established
by UC to advise the president on all aspects of UC's management
responsibilities. UC faculty is represented on external committees
appointed by the Laboratory Director to review the technical
divisions at LANL at least annually. The President's Council provides
an overall assessment of LANL's performance based on the reviews of
the technical divisions. In addition, the council's National Security
Panel visits LANL and Livermore annually to review the work supported
by DOE defense programs and the non-proliferation and national
security programs. Some of the fee paid to UC to manage LANL is
returned to LANL and used, at the discretion of the Laboratory
Director, to support joint research between LANL staff and faculty at
the UC campuses and the four New Mexico research universities. The
strong science-in-national-service focus of UC has enabled LANL to
develop the multidisciplinary science base needed to carry out its
missions.
VI. 57 YEARS OF LANL SCIENCE AND
TECHNOLOGY WITH UC
As our contractor, UC has demanded
all the requirements for great science: excellent staff, collegial
work atmosphere, essential equipment, and experienced peer review.
Consequently, LANL is one of the most highly acclaimed scientific
organizations in the world. As an indicator of our scientific
excellence, peer review, and dissemination of unclassified
information, LANL has more journal publications since 1977 than any
other national laboratory.2 These publications report
important scientific developments in the areas of national security,
energy technology, high-speed computing, and fundamental physics,
chemistry, and life sciences. Some of these accomplishments are
listed in the Appendix.
VII. FUTURE SCIENCE
REQUIREMENTS FOR LANL
LANL's mission in weapons science
is to certify indefinitely the performance, reliability, and safety
of the enduring nuclear weapons stockpile without nuclear testing.
This mission requires the development of new analytical and
experimental techniques and the training of a new cadre of
scientists, engineers, and technicians. In addition to this
challenge, LANL provides technological solutions to a wide range of
equally daunting international issues such as non-proliferation,
counter-terrorism, bio-remediation and mitigation, energy, and
environmental security. To fulfill these defense and societal roles,
LANL must continue to be a multidisciplinary laboratory at the
forefront of science. The solutions to these national problems,
which may have political implications, absolutely require the highest
standards of scientific integrity. To date, LANL has accomplished
these missions by virtue of its strong relationship with
UC.
VIII. POTENTIAL IMPACTS ON LANL SCIENCE IF DOE
CANCELS THE UC CONTRACT
Since the Laboratory's inception
during the Manhattan Project, UC has managed the Laboratory as a
public service. UC's values, reputation, infrastructure, and
experience have served the nation and LANL well. UC has fostered a
professional atmosphere at LANL and nurtured an environment that is
essential for innovation and productivity in both research and
development. We believe that the level of excellence, integrity, and
respect brought to LANL by our UC association could not be matched by
any other potential contractor. If the UC contract were to be
terminated, it would diminish the quality of the LANL R&D efforts
to the detriment of our national missions. It would lead to both a
short and long term attrition of our laboratory scientists and
engineers and greatly impede our ability to attract the best and
brightest of future
generations.
IX. CONCLUSIONS
We can
continue to satisfy LANL's evolving missions only if we maintain and
develop our world-class science capability in many disciplines. We
must have the best people, equipment, and workplace atmosphere to
continue our scientific and technological accomplishments. The
association with UC has been and continues to be critical for the
success of LANL's scientific endeavors. In our opinion, there exists
no institution better qualified to oversee LANL's scientific
activities than the University of California.
Our Laboratory
Director Dr. John Browne has said, "The challenge today and in the
coming decade to ensure the safety and reliability of the US nuclear
deterrent without nuclear testing is as great as any faced in our
history. The University's role is as important now as ever."**
The
Fellows of the Los Alamos National Laboratory concur.
**Testimony by LANL Director Dr. John Browne to the House Oversight
and investigations Subcommittee of the Committee of Commerce on
7/11/00.
APPENDIX: Some Notable LANL
Scientific and Engineering Accomplishments from
1943-2000:3,4
Nuclear Weapons: LANL has
designed, tested, and certified the majority of weapons in the
nation's nuclear stockpile since 1945. LANL developed the first
nuclear weapons (1945); demonstrated the ignition of thermonuclear
fuel (1951); tested the first thermonuclear weapon (1952); developed
VELA satellite verification of atmospheric test-ban treaty (1963);
designed PHERMEX (1963) and DARHT (1999) x-ray radiography facilities
and proton radiography (1995) for the study of the dynamics of dense
matter; used the high-intensity LAMPF proton accelerator for nuclear
weapons studies (1972); developed insensitive high explosives (1974);
and developed CORRTEX to verify underground yields
(1985).
Science and Engineering: LANL constructed the
world's third nuclear reactor (1944) and the first plutonium reactor
(1946); produced the first liquefied helium-3 (1948); developed the
Monte-Carlo (1947) and Sn discrete ordinates method (1953) for
solving radiation transport computations; created the Metropolis
Monte Carlo algorithm (1953); built and tested nuclear powered
rockets (1955); detected the neutrino (1956); demonstrated the first
thermonuclear plasma in laboratory fusion studies (1958); used
plutonium-238 as a space-power source (1959); developed the Stretch
computer in collaboration with IBM (1961); invented heat pipe
technology (1963); produced direct conversion of nuclear to
electrical power by high-temperature thermionic conversion (1967);
built the ultra-high temperature nuclear reactor (1969); used the
high-intensity LAMPF proton accelerator for nuclear studies (1972);
began hot dry rock program (1978); discovered the universality of
chaos in deterministic systems (1979); began the operation the
national database GenBank for nucleic-acid (1982); discovered
heavy-fermion superconductors (1982); invented thermoacoustic heat
engines and refrigerators (1983); published the first edition of
nucleotide-sequence data for HIV samples (1987); created a neutral
particle beam in space (1989); produced the first widely-used
electronic e-print archive (1991); manufactured high-temperature
superconducting wire (1995); demonstrated quantum cryptography
through 40 km of fiber optic cable for the first time (1997); and
demonstrated the feasibility of sending a quantum cryptography key
pad to an earth-orbiting satellite (1999).
These
accomplishments have been possible at LANL only because we have had a
long and illustrious history of having outstanding scientific
personnel. Seven Nobel Laureates have been technically associated
with the Laboratory. In the combined National Academies of Sciences
and Engineering, we have a total of 11 members - more than any other
national laboratory. Many Los Alamos scientists have been honored by
selection as Fellows of their scientific and professional societies
including American Physical Society, American Association for the
Advancement of Science, American Society of Mechanical Engineers,
American Geophysical Union, American Nuclear Society, the Minerals,
Metals and Materials Society, etc. In addition, numerous LANL
scientists have been recipients of prestigious awards for outstanding
achievement as presented by major national and international
scientific and professional societies. This includes more national
R&D 100 winners (63) in the last twelve years than any other
institution.5 This legacy of scientific excellence is the
backbone of LANL and provides the bridge to the future that will
enable us to solve the emerging technological problems of our
society.
REFERENCES
1.
"The University of California as the Contractor of Los Alamos
National Laboratory: An Indispensable Relationship for the
Laboratory, New Mexico, and the United States," Woody Woodruff,
Louis Rosen, Terry Mitchell, Jill Trewhella, and Jeffrey Hay on
behalf of the Fellows of Los Alamos National Laboratory, December 19,
1995.
2. William H. Woodruff, data from SciSearch
Institute for Scientific Information, licensed to the Los Alamos
National Laboratory Research Library, 2000.
3. Los Alamos
Science, "40," Number 7, Winter/Spring 1983.
4.
Los Alamos Science, "The Laboratory's 50th Anniversary,"
Number 21, 1993.
5. "Los Alamos National Laboratory
Science and Technology Assessment," STB-UC-99-106, August,
1999.